10 October 2025

Book Review: Ist das Deutsch oder kann das weg? by Eike Christian Hirsch

Oh, this was a fun read. As a non-native speaker of German, I have always been amazed at how "precise" the German language tends to be. But this book just shows its many imperfections, and yes, as with every other language, there are numerous aspects of German that just doesn't make sense. And this book discusses many such examples. From how meanings change because of a missing comma, to how things have become in fashion such as the use of the colon to indicate a longer than usual pause, this book showcases the many peculiarities that the German language exhibits, when used in daily life. And as I have been reading it, sometimes I just couldn't help but crack up and laugh out loud, given the witty explanations the author provides. Because really, sometimes, if people just take a second look at what they say, sometimes, it just doesn't make sense.

I won't expand on the numerous examples here. But these mistakes happen most of the time because humans don't parse every word they hear. Our brains are efficient, and therefore we try to fill in the blanks so to speak, and sort of hallucinate what we want to understand from a message. So even when we hear a string that has errors, these errors are corrected, and things do make sense. For example, there was a very famous sentence that appeared at some point in the recent years, Eine Kanzlerin, die Krisen kann. This translates roughly to a chancellor, who can (handle) crises. But the verb that indicates what the chancellor actually does with the crises isn't actually specified.

Other such mistakes are also due to the fact that reporters need to pack in so many things in so little space, so headlines sometimes become funny statements. The same goes with advertisements. There's this advertisement for a telecommunications and Internet provider, which said Mega Daten, Mega Preis!. That's an interesting use of Mega, because I assume that the author wanted to say there's going to be a ton of data, but will there also be a ton of price to pay for it?

In any case, this book was small, but definitely a very amusing read. I absolutely had fun going through this one. I give it 4 out of 5 stars, and recommend it to anyone thinking that German is a language that makes sense. It doesn't, sometimes.

See my other book reviews here.